Past Lexington Commanders
- 1689 Leut. David Fiske
- 1699 Capt. William Reed
- 1717 Capt. Joseph Bowman
- 1739 Capt. Benjamin Reed
- 1759 Capt. John Clapham
- * 1761 Capt. Thaddeus Bowman
- * 1775 Capt. John Parker
- * 1775 Capt. John Bridge
- * 1776 Capt. Francis Brown (2nd Co.)
- * 1780 Capt. William Munroe
- * 1780 Capt. Daniel Harrington (2nd Co.)
- * 1784 Capt. Solomon Peirce
- * 1785 Capt. Joseph Smith
- * 1786 Capt. John Smith
- * 1790 Capt. John Chandler Jr.
- * 1796 Capt. Levi Mead
- 1800 Capt. Joseph Smith
- 1805 Capt. Sullivan Burbank
- 1809 Capt. John Chandler III
- 1813 Capt. John Parker Jr.
- 1815 Capt. John Parkhurst Meria
- 1818 Capt. Christopher Reed
- 1819 Capt. Benjamin Reed
- 1821 Capt. William Smith Jr.
- 1825 Capt. Daniel I. Tenney
- 1827 Capt. Loammi Knight
- 1831 Capt. Nathan Wyman
- 1832 Capt. Phillip Russell
- 1834 Capt. Joseph F. LeBaron
- 1835 Capt. Isaac Buttrick
- 1836 Capt. Jonathan S. Parker
- 1844 Capt. William T. Dupee
- 1874 Maj. Loring W. Muzzey
- 1876 Capt. George H. Cutter
- 1910 Maj. Alfred Pierce
- 1914 Maj. George F. Reed
- 1915 Maj. William F. Young
- 1920 Capt. Alfred Pierce
- 1922 Capt. Ezra F. Breed
- 1934 Capt. Fred F. Cook
- 1934 Capt. Charles L. Parker
- 1937 Capt. Claude A. Palmer
- 1942 Capt. Julius Seltzer
- 1949 Capt. Frederick Richardson
- 1953 Capt. John A. Sellars
- 1954 Capt. Norton T. Hood
- 1956 Capt. Donald Guiler
- 1958 Capt. Arthur Brock
- 1959 Capt. Colin Campbell
- 1960 Capt. John Timbury
- 1961 Capt. John E. Ward
- 1964 Capt. Edmund Cady
- 1965 Capt. William F. Fick
- 1968 Maj. George F. Gabriel
- 1971 Capt. James F. Edgar
- 1973 Capt. Robert J. Marrigan
- 1975 Capt. Norman E. Daigle
- 1977 Capt. Joel M. Schulman
- 1979 Capt. Herbert P. Grossimon
- 1981 Capt. Francis E. Belcastro
- 1982 Capt. Thomas B. Sullivan
- 1984 Capt. Charles H. Price Jr.
- 1986 Capt. James E. Hart Jr.
- 1988 Capt. Charles B. Grossimon
- 1990 Capt. Dan E. Sabota
- 1992 Capt. James D. Roberts
- 1994 Capt. Gardner L. Hayward Jr.
- 1996 Capt. Anthony M. Caracino
- 1998 Capt. Saul C. Adamsky
- 2000 Capt. Loran J. Logan
- 2002 Capt. Wayne T. McCarthy
- 2004 Capt. Henry A. Liu
- 2006 Capt. Carlo A. Bertazzoni
- 2008 Capt. William F. Delay
- 2010 Capt. William F. Mix
- 2012 Capt. William J. Poole
- 2014 Capt. Barry J. Cunha
- 2016 Capt. Steve Conners
- 2018 Capt. Larry Conley
- 2020 Capt. David S. Kemper
- 2022 Capt. James Lee
- 2024 Capt. Stephen Cole